![]() ![]() Perhaps they can reverse the fashion judgments of the district court? On the other hand, the appellate judges are, well, appellate judges - one step up in the Article III food chain. The trial judges log more hours in court, including time spent with juries, so perhaps their views are entitled to greater deference. This could be interpreted in different ways. Interestingly enough, the three judges who approve of peep-toe shoes are trial judges, and the two disapproving judges are circuit judges. We have three judges in favor, and two judges opposed. So let’s tally up the responses thus far. ![]() See also the judges at a recent Chicago Bar Association event (recommending against open-toe or peep-toe shoes, especially in front of a jury). It’s best to err on the side of conservative attire in the courtroom. I know an unacceptable peep-toe shoe when I see it. Some are discreet enough to be acceptable. Concurring with Judge Wardlaw is another federal circuit judge, who invoked the spirit of Justice Potter Stewart when we asked her if peep-toe shoes are permissible: Judge Wardlaw and Kat Griffin have company in the “proceed with caution” camp. Don’t wear open-toe shoes unless you’ve seen a much more senior lawyer do it.” This is similar to the advice given to The Careerist by Kat Griffin, former Cahill Gordon associate and founder of Corporette (whom we previously profiled): “ closed-toe shoe is the preference. It’s better to play it safe in formal settings and save the peep-toes for after hours. You just never know how your audience - judges, jurors, clients or senior partners - will react. Women appearing in court should never wear anything that draws attention to their anatomy over the merits of their case. My view is that if you have a question about the appropriateness of your attire, don’t risk it. Take Supreme Court shortlister Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw - a current Ninth Circuit judge, former trial judge, and former litigation partner at O’Melveny & Myers. Judges Gertner and Kobayashi: you’re the judges! You can wear whatever you like underneath your robe - and people will always compliment you, no matter what (although deservedly so, in the case of these fashionable jurists).Īnd some women judges respectfully dissent. And at least two of them, Judges Gertner and Kobayashi, admit to wearing such shoes to court themselves.īut let’s play devil’s advocate. So Judges Gertner, Kobayashi and Mollway - three seasoned trial judges, who have seen a lot of female feet in their courtrooms - are fine with peep-toe shoes. (“Toe cleavage,” Your Honor? Well, if it there’s a Wikipedia entry for it, then it’s clearly a real phenomenon.) ![]() I have heard it said that some people object to ‘toe cleavage,’ but I do not. Fukino, which we recently wrote about - concurred: Haw.) - author of the colorful opinion in Gustafson v. Judge Kobayashi’s colleague, Chief Judge Susan Oki Mollway (D. I do think it is acceptable, and I do wear them in court myself. On the other side of the country, Magistrate Judge Leslie Kobayashi of Hawaii - a former trial lawyer and prosecutor, and President Obama’s nominee to the vacant district court judgeship in that tropical paradise - had this to say: In approving of peep-toe shoes, Judge Gertner is not alone. Just because you’re liberal - and Judge Gertner is definitely left-of-center, to put it mildly - doesn’t mean you have to be frumpy.) (In addition, having had her as a professor in law school, I can attest that Judge Gertner is super-stylish. She has been a trial judge for over 15 years, since 1994, and before that she was a highly successful litigatrix, known for her high-profile criminal defense and civil rights cases. Judge Gertner is a reliable authority on these matters. London, England: V&A Publications, 1999.As legal demand and firm capacities fluctuate, firm leaders must find ways to provide clients with swift and responsive legal services and prioritize lawyer work-life… From BigHand According to Lucy Pratt and Linda Woolley in their book Shoes, during World War II (1939 –45) peep-toed shoes were banned as "frivolous and potentially 'dangerous.'" But when the war ended, women craving the glamour and feminine styling of high-heeled, peep-toed shoes brought the style back into favor. Once open-toed shoes were only proper to wear on vacations at resorts, but now peep-toes shoes became acceptable for many daytime leisure activities. Peep-toed shoes came in a variety of styles, but they typically had a high heel, a small upper that covered the sides of the foot and the instep, a strap around the heel and, of course, a small hole in the upper, right at the point of the shoe, that revealed the toes. One of the more popular women's shoe styles of the 1930s was the peep-toed shoe, so named for the provocative view that it offered of the tips of the toes. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |